# Positioning: Who It's For and Why It's Better

> What positioning is, April Dunford's five components in order, why 'for everyone' fails, how to test it, and a worked example with a before/after headline.

- Author: Tai Pham Phu
- Published: 18 Nov 2026
- Tags: Startups, Positioning, Marketing, Product, Entrepreneurship
- URL: https://phamphutai.com/2026/11/18/positioning-who-its-for-and-why-its-better/

April Dunford's first job out of school was product marketing at a small software startup. The product was a desktop database that spoke SQL, pitched as a rival to Microsoft Access. After a lot of marketing it had sold barely 200 copies, and the company was getting ready to shut it down.

Before killing it, someone had to phone the people who had bought it. That job fell to Dunford. She told the story years later in [a guest post for Lenny's Newsletter](https://www.lennysnewsletter.com/p/positioning) (January 26, 2021).

The first 20 calls went the same way. People didn't remember buying it, or bought it and stopped using it. Then call 21 was different. A manager said his sales reps used it on laptops in the field to take orders, and it synced those orders back to the main database at head office. In his words: "Your product made me the hero of the sales team!" A few calls later, another customer said the same thing about field service staff.

Across 100 customers, 94 barely knew they owned it. **Six said it had changed their business.** The happy ones she describes were doing the same kind of thing: running a small database on a mobile device that synced with a big one.

The company didn't change the code. It changed the story. The product was repositioned as an **embeddable database for mobile devices**. Dunford writes that it then took off, was bought by a large database company, and grew into a product family worth hundreds of millions in revenue.

Same product. Different answer to "what is this, and who is it for?" That answer is **positioning**. This post covers what it is, Dunford's five components, why "for everyone" fails, a classic template, honest tests, and a worked example ending in a before/after homepage line.

---

## What positioning actually is

**Positioning is the context you put around your product so its value is obvious to the right people.**

Dunford's short definition is that positioning describes how your product is the best at delivering some value that a clearly defined group of customers cares a lot about. Notice the three parts: *best at something*, *some value*, *a defined group*. Leave any one out and it stops working.

Buyers never judge a product in a vacuum. The moment they see it, they put it in a box: "Oh, it's a CRM." That box decides:

- **who they compare you with,**
- **which features they expect,**
- **what price feels fair.**

The desktop database was judged against Microsoft Access, and lost. The same code judged as a mobile database had almost no competition. **The product didn't get better. The box changed.**

Positioning is not messaging. **Positioning is the strategy** (who it's for, what it beats, why it's better). Messaging is the words on the homepage and in the sales deck that carry it. Write the homepage before deciding the positioning and you get nice words wrapped around nothing.

---

## Why "it's for everyone" fails

Almost every first-time founder says some version of this: "Anyone could use it." It feels safe. Why turn customers away?

What actually happens when you talk to everyone:

- **Your homepage gets vague.** "The all-in-one platform for modern teams" fits a thousand products. Nobody reads it and thinks "that's for me."
- **You get compared with the biggest name.** If you're "project management for everyone," you're up against tools with hundreds of engineers. You'll look small and unfinished.
- **Your strengths disappear.** A feature that is gold to one group is noise to another. Averaged across everyone, it's noise.
- **Sales take forever.** Every call starts from zero.

Dunford's Janna Systems story shows the opposite. She ran marketing at Janna, a small CRM (customer relationship management) company competing head-on with Siebel Systems. By her account, Siebel had about 8,000 staff and $2 billion in revenue. Janna had a couple of dozen people, under $2 million in revenue and six customers.

Janna's odd strength was that it tracked relationships between *people*, not just companies. Two people on the same board at different firms, for example. In demos the team couldn't say why that mattered. Then a deal with an investment bank made it obvious: in banking, deals move through personal relationships, and knowing who knows whom is the whole game.

So Janna stopped being "enterprise CRM" and became **CRM for investment banks**. Dunford writes that revenue went from under $2 million to close to $80 million in about 18 months. In September 2000, Siebel agreed to buy Janna in a stock deal that [Computerworld reported](https://www.computerworld.com/article/1390315/siebel-gobbles-up-another-crm-software-rival.html) at $975 million, naming customers like Merrill Lynch and Lehman Brothers. (Dunford gives a different, larger figure; I'm using the one reported at the time.)

**Narrowing didn't shrink Janna. It made Janna the obvious choice for someone.** That's the trade: you give up being a weak option for everyone to become the strong option for a few. Later you can widen, one segment at a time.

---

## The five components, in order

In *Obviously Awesome* (2019), Dunford breaks positioning into five components plus one optional extra. Book summaries such as [Readingraphics'](https://readingraphics.com/book-summary-obviously-awesome/) list them like this, and her Lenny's Newsletter guide uses the same five in the same order:

1. **Competitive alternatives:** what customers would use if you didn't exist.
2. **Unique attributes:** what you have that those alternatives don't.
3. **Value (and proof):** what those attributes let customers do.
4. **Best-fit customers:** who cares most about that value. The book calls this "target market characteristics."
5. **Market category:** the frame that makes that value obvious.
6. **Relevant trends (optional):** a trend your buyers already care about that makes you timely.

The order matters. Each step depends on the one before it. You can't name your unique attributes until you know what you're being compared with. You can't describe value until you know the attributes. And you can't choose a category until you know who you're trying to win.

<figure class="diagram">
<svg viewBox="0 0 680 300" role="img" aria-label="A chain of five boxes connected by arrows: competitive alternatives, unique attributes, value, best-fit customers, market category. Under each is the question it answers. A dashed box for relevant trends, marked optional, points into market category. A dashed line loops back from market category to competitive alternatives with the note: if any step is weak, go back a step." xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg">
<defs>
<marker id="pos-arrow" viewBox="0 0 10 10" refX="9" refY="5" markerWidth="7" markerHeight="7" orient="auto-start-reverse">
<path d="M0 0 L10 5 L0 10 z" fill="currentColor"/>
</marker>
</defs>
<text x="20" y="26" font-size="14">Positioning is a chain: each step depends on the one before</text>
<rect x="20" y="60" width="112" height="56" rx="6" fill="currentColor"/>
<text x="76" y="84" font-size="12" text-anchor="middle" class="on-fg">Competitive</text>
<text x="76" y="100" font-size="12" text-anchor="middle" class="on-fg">alternatives</text>
<rect x="152" y="60" width="112" height="56" rx="6" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="1.5"/>
<text x="208" y="84" font-size="12" text-anchor="middle">Unique</text>
<text x="208" y="100" font-size="12" text-anchor="middle">attributes</text>
<rect x="284" y="60" width="112" height="56" rx="6" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="1.5"/>
<text x="340" y="92" font-size="12" text-anchor="middle">Value</text>
<rect x="416" y="60" width="112" height="56" rx="6" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="1.5"/>
<text x="472" y="84" font-size="12" text-anchor="middle">Best-fit</text>
<text x="472" y="100" font-size="12" text-anchor="middle">customers</text>
<rect x="548" y="60" width="112" height="56" rx="6" fill="currentColor"/>
<text x="604" y="84" font-size="12" text-anchor="middle" class="on-fg">Market</text>
<text x="604" y="100" font-size="12" text-anchor="middle" class="on-fg">category</text>
<line x1="132" y1="88" x2="150" y2="88" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="1.5" marker-end="url(#pos-arrow)"/>
<line x1="264" y1="88" x2="282" y2="88" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="1.5" marker-end="url(#pos-arrow)"/>
<line x1="396" y1="88" x2="414" y2="88" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="1.5" marker-end="url(#pos-arrow)"/>
<line x1="528" y1="88" x2="546" y2="88" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="1.5" marker-end="url(#pos-arrow)"/>
<text x="76" y="138" font-size="11" text-anchor="middle" class="muted">What would they</text>
<text x="76" y="152" font-size="11" text-anchor="middle" class="muted">use instead?</text>
<text x="208" y="138" font-size="11" text-anchor="middle" class="muted">What do you have</text>
<text x="208" y="152" font-size="11" text-anchor="middle" class="muted">that they lack?</text>
<text x="340" y="138" font-size="11" text-anchor="middle" class="muted">What does that</text>
<text x="340" y="152" font-size="11" text-anchor="middle" class="muted">let people do?</text>
<text x="472" y="138" font-size="11" text-anchor="middle" class="muted">Who cares about</text>
<text x="472" y="152" font-size="11" text-anchor="middle" class="muted">that the most?</text>
<text x="604" y="138" font-size="11" text-anchor="middle" class="muted">What frame makes</text>
<text x="604" y="152" font-size="11" text-anchor="middle" class="muted">it obvious?</text>
<rect x="416" y="186" width="120" height="44" rx="6" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="1.2" stroke-dasharray="5 4"/>
<text x="476" y="205" font-size="12" text-anchor="middle">Relevant trends</text>
<text x="476" y="221" font-size="11" text-anchor="middle" class="muted">(optional)</text>
<line x1="536" y1="200" x2="586" y2="164" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="1.2" marker-end="url(#pos-arrow)"/>
<path d="M640 162 L640 252 L76 252 L76 162" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="1.2" stroke-dasharray="5 4" marker-end="url(#pos-arrow)"/>
<text x="312" y="274" font-size="12" text-anchor="middle" class="muted">If any step is weak, go back a step and redo it</text>
</svg>
<figcaption>Start from what customers would do without you; the category comes last, because it only makes sense once you know who you're winning and why.</figcaption>
</figure>

### 1. Competitive alternatives: start with what they'd do without you

Ask: **if your product vanished tomorrow, what would your customers do instead?**

The honest answer is rarely "a competitor with a slick website." Dunford's guide lists the usual suspects: a spreadsheet, a manual process, or hiring an intern. She also writes that in enterprise software, roughly a quarter of deals are lost to "no decision," meaning the buyer just keeps doing what they did before.

I've written a whole post on this: [your real competitor is often a spreadsheet](https://phamphutai.com/2026/10/06/your-real-competitor-is-a-spreadsheet/). The spreadsheet is free, already open, and bent into exactly the shape the owner wants. "Doing nothing" is free too, and it carries zero risk of a failed rollout.

**Everything after this step is relative.** "Fast" means nothing alone. Faster than typing receipts by hand is a story.

Get this answer from your **happiest customers**, not your own guess.

### 2. Unique attributes: what you have that the alternatives don't

List what you can do that the alternatives can't. Features count, but so do other things: how you deliver it, your business model, your expertise, a dataset, an integration, local support, the language you work in.

Two rules. **Unique compared with the alternatives from step 1**, not with every product on earth: if the alternative is a spreadsheet, "automatic reminders" is unique even though 50 other apps have them. And **list first, judge later**: Janna's relationship mapping looked like a weird extra until someone saw what it was good for.

### 3. Value: what those attributes let people do

Customers don't buy attributes. They buy what the attributes let them do. Dunford's own [positioning exercise post](https://www.aprildunford.com/post/a-product-positioning-exercise) says roughly this: customers care about what your features do for them, not the features themselves.

Turn each attribute into "so that..." statements. Then group them. Most products end up with **one to four value themes**, not twelve.

Add **proof** wherever you can: a measured time saving, a before/after from a real customer, a number you can defend. "Saves time" is a claim. "Month-end close went from five days to two at three of our customers" is value with proof. (Only ever use proof that's real.)

Slack is a famous example of thinking at the value level. On July 31, 2013, just before Slack's preview launch, Stewart Butterfield sent his team a memo later published as "We Don't Sell Saddles Here" (reprinted in full [here](https://www.alexanderjarvis.com/we-dont-sell-saddles-here-memo-from-slack/)). His analogy: a saddle company could sell saddles, or it could sell horseback riding. He told the team they were unlikely to sell "a group chat system" very well. Instead, he wrote, "what we're selling is organizational transformation." The features were chat. The value was a team that worked differently.

### 4. Best-fit customers: who cares most

Lots of people *might* like your product. A few will **care a lot**. Dunford puts it this way in the exercise post: many prospects care about what you deliver, but only some really care.

Describe the best-fit customer by **things you can spot from the outside**, not just demographics. "Small businesses" is too wide. "Bookkeeping firms with 3 to 20 staff that process paper receipts for dozens of small clients every month" is something a salesperson can find on a map and a founder can find in a Facebook group.

Good characteristics explain *why* the value matters more to them: they do the painful task often, the pain lands on someone who can buy, and the alternative is clearly bad for them specifically.

This is the same idea as Superhuman's segment work in the [product-market fit post](https://phamphutai.com/2026/11/17/product-market-fit-how-to-know/): find the group that pulls hardest, and build and sell for them.

### 5. Market category: the frame that makes it obvious

Now pick the **box** you want buyers to put you in: the one that makes your value obvious at a glance.

Dunford's guide makes a point I think every early founder should hear: creating a brand-new category is usually expensive and slow. She notes that most tech companies that went public in the previous five years were positioned in **existing** markets, and that early category creators often lose to later entrants (Google wasn't the first search engine; Facebook wasn't the first social network).

Your options, easiest first:

| Option | What it means | When it works |
|---|---|---|
| Existing category, as is | "We're an X" | Your strengths are the ones buyers in X already value |
| Existing category, narrowed | "We're X for Y" | Your strength matters hugely to one segment (Janna: CRM for investment banks) |
| New category | "We're the first Z" | Rarely early; needs money and time to teach the market |

"X for Y" is underrated. It borrows everything buyers already understand about X, then says "built for people like you."

### Plus: relevant trends (optional)

A trend your buyers already care about (in 2026, usually AI) can make you feel timely. Use it only if it's tied to your value. **A trend is seasoning, not the meal.**

---

## The classic template (and why it comes last)

Before Dunford, the most famous positioning tool was Geoffrey Moore's "elevator test" from *Crossing the Chasm* (first published 1991, revised in 1999 and 2014). The structure, as reproduced by [Unusual Ventures](https://www.unusual.vc/post/crossing-the-enterprise-chasm-geoffrey-moore), goes like this:

> **For** [target customers, your beachhead segment only]
> **who are dissatisfied with** [the current market alternative],
> **our product is a** [product category]
> **that provides** [compelling reason to buy].
> **Unlike** [the product alternative],
> **we have assembled** [key whole-product features for your specific application].

You'll see many slightly different versions online. The core is always the same: who, what they use today, your category, your reason to buy, and how you differ.

Look at the blanks. They map closely onto Dunford's components: target customers, alternatives, category, value, unique attributes. The template is a good **container**. Its weakness is that filling in blanks doesn't tell you *what* to put in them. (Dunford's book page makes a similar point, setting her method against filling in an old-school positioning statement.) Founders fill it with wishes: "For businesses who want to be more productive, our product is an all-in-one platform..."

**Do the five steps first, then pour the answers into the template.** It's a summary, not a method.

---

## How to test positioning honestly

Positioning is a guess until customers react to it. Two cheap tests:

### Test 1: Sales calls

Sales calls are your best positioning lab. Signs it's working:

- **People get it in the first minute.** You stop spending half the call explaining what the product is.
- **They compare you with the alternative you expected.** If you positioned against spreadsheets and they keep asking "how are you different from Big Brand X?", your category is pulling them to the wrong comparison.

Write down each prospect's first question. If most are "so what does it do?", it isn't landing.

### Test 2: The homepage headline and the 5-second test

The **five-second test** was described by Christine Perfetti at UIE in 2005 ([original article](https://articles.centercentre.com/?p=85)): show someone a page for five seconds, hide it, then ask what they remember.

For positioning, ask three questions after the five seconds:

1. What does this product do?
2. Who is it for?
3. Why would someone pick it over what they use now?

If most people can answer the first two in their own words, the headline is clear. The third question is the hard one.

Be honest about what this test can and can't do:

- **It tests clarity, not desire.** People can understand a headline perfectly and still not want the product.
- **Ask the right people.** Five friends who are developers will "get" a dev-tool headline that confuses an actual bookkeeper. Test with people who look like your best-fit customer.
- **Small samples are noisy.** Five or ten people catch a confusing headline, but can't tell you which of two good ones converts better.

Use it to catch fog; let sales and sign-ups judge the rest.

---

## Worked example: from fog to focus

Here's a **fictional** company, taken through every step. All names and numbers are made up for illustration.

**Formwise (fictional)** reads documents with AI. Upload a PDF or a photo, and it pulls the data out into structured fields. It has 50 paying accounts and slow growth. Its homepage says:

> **Before:** "AI-powered document workflows for modern teams."

That line fits a hundred products. Which team? What workflow? Compared with what?

**Step 0: talk to the happiest customers.** The founders pick the 12 accounts that use Formwise most. Nine of the 12 (75%) turn out to be small bookkeeping firms. They photograph clients' paper receipts and invoices, and Formwise turns them into rows they paste into their accounting templates.

**Step 1: competitive alternatives.** What did those nine firms do before? Junior staff typed receipts into Excel by hand. A couple had tried a generic OCR app (OCR, optical character recognition, means software that turns images of text into text). They gave up because it read the text but didn't put it in the right columns.

**Step 2: unique attributes**, compared with hand-typing and generic OCR:

- Reads receipts in both English and the local language.
- Maps each line to the client's own chart of accounts (the list of categories a bookkeeper files money under).
- Flags likely duplicate receipts.
- Exports straight into the Excel template the firm already uses.

**Step 3: value.** The founders measure a typical firm with 40 clients, each sending about 120 receipts a month. That's 4,800 receipts. Typing each by hand takes about 1.5 minutes: **120 hours a month**. Checking Formwise's output takes about 0.3 minutes per receipt: **24 hours**. That's **96 hours a month back, an 80% cut**, mostly in the month-end crunch. Two value themes come out of it:

- **Month-end without the all-nighters** (time).
- **Fewer missed or double-counted receipts** (accuracy).

**Step 4: best-fit customers.** Bookkeeping firms with roughly 3 to 20 staff, serving 20 to 80 small-business clients, with clients who still hand over paper receipts. The owner feels the month-end pain directly and can say yes on the call.

**Step 5: market category.** Three options:

| Category | What buyers compare it with | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| "AI document platform" | Large enterprise document tools | Formwise looks small and unfinished |
| "OCR app" | Free scanner apps | Looks like a commodity; price feels too high |
| "Receipt entry for bookkeeping firms" | Hand-typing in Excel | Value is obvious; the alternative is clearly worse |

They pick the third: an existing idea (receipt capture) narrowed to one segment.

**Trend (optional):** AI is real here, so it stays, but as the *how*, not the headline.

**Moore-style summary:**

> For small bookkeeping firms who are tired of typing client receipts into Excel at month-end, Formwise is receipt entry software that turns photos of receipts into rows in your own accounting template. Unlike generic OCR apps, it files each line under your client's chart of accounts and flags duplicates.

**After** (homepage headline and subline):

> **"Stop typing client receipts at month-end."**
> Formwise turns receipt photos into rows in your Excel template, already sorted into your client's accounts. Built for bookkeeping firms.

Run the 5-second test on that with a handful of bookkeepers. If they say "it types up receipts for accountants," it's working. Then the real test: do more sales calls end in a trial, and do the trials stick? (The [cohort retention post](https://phamphutai.com/2026/11/17/cohort-retention-the-chart-that-tells-the-truth/) shows how to check that last part.)

Nothing about the product changed. The accounts that aren't bookkeeping firms still exist, and Formwise doesn't have to turn them away. It just stops *writing for* them.

---

## Common positioning mistakes

- **Keeping the default position.** Dunford's exercise post warns that weak positioning usually comes from hanging on to the market you started in. You built a "project tool" on day one, so it stays a project tool forever, even when customers use it for something else.
- **Positioning against the wrong rival.** You obsess over the startup down the road while customers are actually choosing between you and a spreadsheet.
- **Claiming a category you can't win.** Calling yourself "a CRM" puts you next to Salesforce. "CRM for investment banks" put Janna next to nobody.
- **Never writing it down.** Sales, product and the homepage each tell a slightly different story. Write it down, date it, revisit it when evidence changes.

Positioning also changes **how you price**. The box you're in sets the comparison. A tool positioned against hand-typing is priced against hours of staff time; the same tool positioned as an "OCR app" is priced against free. More on that in [How to Price a SaaS or API](https://phamphutai.com/2026/11/18/how-to-price-a-saas-or-api/). And once you know who it's for, you know where to find them, which is the subject of [Distribution Beats Product](https://phamphutai.com/2026/11/18/distribution-beats-product/).

---

## Key ideas

- **Positioning is context.** It decides who buyers compare you with, what they expect and what price feels fair.
- **"For everyone" means "for no one."** Narrowing to the group that cares most makes you the obvious choice for someone, as Janna's "CRM for investment banks" did.
- **Work Dunford's components in order:** competitive alternatives, unique attributes, value, best-fit customers, market category, plus an optional trend.
- **The real alternative is often a spreadsheet, a manual process or doing nothing.** Your uniqueness and value are measured against that.
- **Moore's template is a container, not a method.** Do the steps first, then fill it in.
- **Test it in sales calls and with a 5-second headline test**, honestly: the test checks clarity, and only real sales and retention check desire.
- **The same product can win or lose on positioning alone**, as Dunford's 94-versus-6 database calls showed.

---

*Sources: April Dunford, [A quickstart guide to positioning](https://www.lennysnewsletter.com/p/positioning) (Lenny's Newsletter, January 26, 2021); April Dunford, [A Product Positioning Exercise](https://www.aprildunford.com/post/a-product-positioning-exercise) (October 17, 2019); Readingraphics, [Book summary of Obviously Awesome](https://readingraphics.com/book-summary-obviously-awesome/); Computerworld, [Siebel gobbles up another CRM software rival](https://www.computerworld.com/article/1390315/siebel-gobbles-up-another-crm-software-rival.html) (September 2000); Stewart Butterfield, "We Don't Sell Saddles Here" (memo of July 31, 2013, [reprinted here](https://www.alexanderjarvis.com/we-dont-sell-saddles-here-memo-from-slack/)); Unusual Ventures, [Crossing the enterprise chasm: Lessons from Geoffrey Moore](https://www.unusual.vc/post/crossing-the-enterprise-chasm-geoffrey-moore) (May 7, 2025); Christine Perfetti, [5-Second Tests: Measuring Your Site's Content Pages](https://articles.centercentre.com/?p=85) (UIE, 2005).*

*Related: [Your Real Competitor Is a Spreadsheet](https://phamphutai.com/2026/10/06/your-real-competitor-is-a-spreadsheet/), [Product-Market Fit: How to Know You Have It](https://phamphutai.com/2026/11/17/product-market-fit-how-to-know/), and [Your First 10 Customers](https://phamphutai.com/2026/11/11/your-first-10-customers/).*
